When Belonging Comes With a Question Mark

Ever since I was a little girl, I knew I was Muslim. It was simply a part of who I was, much like being Indian. I never imagined how much weight that identity would come to carry.
As a child, I did not think much about being a minority. I was Indian, just like everyone around me. I belonged to the same country, spoke the same languages, went to the same schools, and shared so many of the same experiences.
It was only as I grew older that I began to understand something uncomfortable. While I had never questioned my belonging, every once in a while, someone around me would make me feel as though I was somehow less Indian than they were.
Not everyone. Not even most people I knew. But enough people, and enough times, for that feeling to settle somewhere in the back of my mind. Like a bitter aftertaste that never quite goes away.
I remember something from eighth grade.
One of my close friends casually said that Muslims were “na ghar ke, na ghaat ke.”
It is a Hindi expression, often associated with the saying “dhobi ka kutta, na ghar ka, na ghaat ka,” referring to someone who belongs neither here nor there.
Imagine being a little girl and hearing that the community you belong to does not really belong anywhere.
The strange thing is, I did not fully understand the weight of those words at the time. It took me years to look back and realize how deeply troubling that moment was.
I do not blame my friend. She was a child, just like me. Perhaps she was repeating something she had heard from the adults around her. I cannot know for certain.
But it makes me wonder about the conversations children grow up hearing. What are we teaching them about people who pray differently, look different, or come from different backgrounds?
Children are not born knowing whom to exclude. Somewhere along the way, they learn how to draw those lines.
And I wish we spent more time teaching them how to erase them.
As I grew older, there were other comments, other experiences, and other moments that reminded me of my Muslim identity in ways I had never asked to be reminded.
Sometimes the comments were direct. Sometimes they were disguised as jokes. And sometimes they were simply things people said without considering who might be listening.
I learned that prejudice does not always arrive loudly. Sometimes it comes from familiar faces, ordinary conversations, and people who otherwise seem perfectly kind.
And perhaps that is what makes it so difficult to explain.
Recently, I came across a video shared by the mother of one of my children’s classmates. The video featured someone openly criticizing the Muslim community in a way I found deeply prejudiced.
My first reaction was anger.
But then came something much heavier.
I thought about my children.
For a moment, I was no longer the little girl in eighth grade trying to understand why someone thought she did not belong. I was a mother wondering whether her children would someday carry the same questions.
Would someone make them feel less worthy because of their faith? Would they have to defend an identity they never thought needed defending? Would they, too, learn to recognize that bitter aftertaste?
And for one heartbreaking moment, I almost wanted to apologize to them.
Apologize for a burden they never asked to carry. For the possibility that the world might sometimes judge them before getting to know them.
But then I realized something.
I do not want to raise my children to apologize for who they are.
I want to raise them to be proud of their identity without feeling superior to anyone else. To respect other religions without questioning the worth of their own. To understand that belonging is not something another person gets to grant or take away.
And perhaps most importantly, I want them to be kind without being afraid to stand up for themselves.
I do not want my experiences to become their fears.
I want them to become lessons.
Because I still believe that people are capable of learning, changing, and doing better. I have known kindness across religious and cultural differences, too, and I refuse to let the uglier moments erase those experiences.
This is not a story about hating a country or its people. India will always be part of who I am. It is a story about wanting to feel that the country I have always called mine belongs to me just as much as it belongs to anyone else.
And now, as a mother, it is about wanting something even simpler for my children.
That they grow up knowing they belong, without ever feeling the need to prove it.
Perhaps that is where change begins. Not with grand speeches or arguments, but with the things we say around our dinner tables, the conversations we have with our children, and the kindness we choose when someone is different from us.
After all, no child should have to grow up wondering whether they belong in the only world they have ever known.
Leave a note